Entrepreneurship -
Filing for a Patent Versus Keeping Your Invention a Trade Secret - Sun and Planets Spirituality AYINRIN
From The Palace Of Kabiesi Ebo Afin!Ebo Afin Kabiesi! His Magnificence Oloja Elejio Oba Olofin Pele Joshua Obasa De Medici Osangangan broad-daylight natural blood line 100% Royalty The God, LLB Hons, BL, Warlord, Bonafide King of Ile Ife kingdom and Bonafide King of Ijero Kingdom, Number 1 Sun worshiper in the Whole World.I'm His Magnificence the Crown.
For Spiritual Consultations, Spiritual divination reading, Guidance and Counseling, spiritual products and spiritual Services, offering of Spiritual Declarations , call or text Palace and Temple Phone and Whatsapp contact: +2348166343145, Phone And WhatsApp Contact : +2347019686274 ,Mail: obanifa87@gmail.com, Facebook page: Sun Spirituality.Website:www.sunspirituality.com.
Our Sun spiritual Temple deliver Spiritual Services to Companies owners, CEOs, Business brands owners, Bankers, Technologists, Monarchs, Military officers, Entrepreneurs, Top Hierarchy State Politicians, and any Public figures across the planet.
Author:His Magnificence the Crown, Kabiesi Ebo Afin! Oloja Elejio Oba Olofin Pele Joshua Obasa De Medici Osangangan Broadaylight.
For
many years, beginning in 1942, Premarin was the only hormone
replacement therapy drug on the market derived from a natural source.
The drug, provided as a treatment for negative symptoms of menopause,
became the most widely prescribed drug in the US and Canada during that
time. Wyeth, a pharmaceutical acquired by Pfizer in 2009, was the sole
supplier of Premarin. A series of patents were issued on the drug in the
1940s, but long after they had expired, there were still no generic
competitors on the market. How could Wyeth sustain this exclusivity for
such an extended period of time, decades beyond the 20 years of the
patent’s term?
The
answer is that no one succeeded at duplicating the extraction process,
which Wyeth had not patented, but rather kept as a trade secret. The key
ingredient in Premarin is conjugated estrogens extracted from pregnant
mare urine. That’s right. The secret sauce of the multimillion drug is
horse pee, and the process for extracting the equine estrogens was kept
in Wyeth’s manufacturing plant in Brandon, Canada. While heated debates
continue over the impact of the patent wars on market competitiveness,
the implications trade secrets are more likely to be misunderstood.
Trade secrets are thought to be the real workhorse of the knowledge
economy, because of their pervasive importance. At the same time, trade
secrets are viewed as the stepchild of intellectual property because
they operate, by definition, in secrecy, and we know much less about
their role in market competition than we know about patents, copyrights,
and trademarks.
Why
do some companies choose to patent their innovation while others choose
to hide it? Compare the paradigmatic early American trade secret – the
one and only recipe for Coca Cola – to the paradigmatic patent – the
telephone. Alexander Graham Bell patented the telephone in 1876 as
United States Patent No. 174,465, the most valuable patent in history. Ten years later, in 1886, Dr. John Pemberton created what is now the world’s most famous trade secret: the Coca-Cola formula. Insiders know it as Merchandise 7X.
No single contractor has the full recipe; each is tasked to prepare
only parts of the classic blend. The company has kept the secret for
over a century by purportedly storing it in a vault in downtown Atlanta,
and restricting access to only a handful of executives. Coca Cola could
have patented the formula, but that would only give the company twenty
years of exclusivity rights to their classic taste. Instead the formula
is locked up, literally and indefinitely.
A
well-kept trade secret could theoretically last forever. But there is a
risk. Unlike with patents, it is perfectly legal to reverse engineer
and copy a trade secret. A patent lasts only 20 years, but during
that period, the protection is far stronger: independent invention is
no defense in a patent suit. In 1998, a group of horse ranchers suddenly
set up a production facility and filed an Abbreviated New Drug Application (ANDA) for a generic version of Premarin.
They claimed to have succeeded in mare urine extraction where others
had failed. This, of course, represented a serious threat to a hugely
profitable product. If the horse ranchers had indeed been independently
and honestly lucky in their discovery, Wyeth would have lost its market
dominance. Such was not the case. Wyeth launched an extensive, and
expensive, investigation leading to evidence that the horse ranchers had
improperly encouraged one of Wyeth’s own former scientists to provide
the secrets to the manufacturing process. The court issued a sweeping
and devastating judgment against these new competitors, ordering a
permanent stop to the use of the trade secret.
Patents
and trade secrets present opposing choices. Trade secrets derive their
legal protection from their inherently secret nature. Patents, by
contrast, can only be protected through public disclosure. In fact, a
patent will be invalidated if the inventor refrains from describing
important details. This requirement, called enablement, requires a patentee to disclose enough information for others to use the invention after the patent has expired.
Budget
constraints and the costs for filing a patent force a smart evaluation
of your options. When facing the choice of patenting or hiding a
valuable innovation, you must first ask yourself whether the invention
is patentable at all. Does is it meet the legal requirements of
non-obviousness, novelty, and usefulness to be granted a patent? Even if
it does, ask yourself:
- Will the invention be useful beyond 20 years?
- Is it possible for other companies to reverse engineer it?
- Is the invention detectable and embedded in the product itself or is it part of an internal manufacturing process?
- Is the invention likely to be independently discovered in the near future?
- Is the product regularly observed in public settings?
The
answers to these questions are company- and invention-specific. A
company that has high turnover among its employees and that uses a range
of partners in its production process might rightly fear going the path
of trade secrets.
Importantly,
as with Premarin, trade secret law and patent law can coexist.
Different forms of intellectual property rights can be used to protect
valuable information. Patents often protect the broad concept, while
trade secrets protect the production details. The Leahy-Smith America Invents Act
was passed into law in 2011 and most of its provisions came into effect
earlier this year. The law lowers the disclosure requirements for
inventions, for the first time effectively removing the threat of
invalidating a patent for failure to disclose the best mode of
implementation. This may lead inventors to rely more on the dual
strategy of patent and trade secret protection for a single invention.
Another
important change in the recent patent reform is a defense against
claims of patent infringement for anyone who commercially used an
invention, even if in secret, at least one year before the patent
filing. This change may further tip the balance for more reliance on
secrecy for certain innovations.
These
choices are strategic, and a company must think about the broader
picture too of the overall intangible assets your company possesses. The
different forms of protection should be understood as an asset
portfolio – you might want to diversify and spread your risk. A friend
of mine who is the Vice President of a highly innovative company in the
shipping industry appropriately describes intellectual property
protection as a volume business: “You never know what will be the
diamond in the rough.”
Was this article helpful? Connect with me.
Follow The SUN (AYINRIN), Follow the light. Be bless. I am His Magnificence, The Crown, Kabiesi Ebo Afin!Ebo Afin Kabiesi! His Magnificence Oloja Elejio Oba Olofin Pele Joshua Obasa De Medici Osangangan broad-daylight natural blood line 100% Royalty The God, LLB Hons, BL, Warlord, Bonafide King of Ile Ife kingdom and Bonafide King of Ijero Kingdom, Number 1 Sun worshiper in the Whole World.I'm His Magnificence the Crown. Follow the light.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.